Keep the idea, change the move

When your first move for an idea fails to your opponent's reply, don't drop the idea. Say it in words and find another move that does the same job.

Lesson 4 of 5 in Blunder check · about 7 min · 2-question quiz

Lesson notes

The whole lesson in text, with the answers. Play it on the board above first.

  1. You are Black. If the rook on e1 leaves the back rank, your rook mates on f1. A knight check on e2 forks king and queen and seems to win. But after the captures on e2, White has a knight check on f6. Find another move with the same idea.

    Qe2. The queen attacks one rook and offers herself to the other. If the rook on e1 takes, the knight takes back with check and the rook mates. So the other rook takes.

  2. White's knight check on f6 never came, because this time your knight arrives with check first. Take back with check.

    Nxe2+. If the rook takes the knight, your rook mates on f1. The king steps into the corner.

  3. Taking the queen is good enough. There is a mate in two. Find it.

    Rf1+. The rook has to take.

  4. And the second rook.

    Rxf1#. Checkmate, with the knight covering g1. The idea was the same all along: pull the rook away from the back rank. Only the first move changed.

  5. Black to move. The same idea: if the rook leaves d1, your rook mates on f1. Your queen can attack that rook from d4, d5 or d6. On d4 nobody can take her, so it looks strongest. Look at White's checks first, then choose.

    Qd6. The queen attacks the rook and the knight, and she looks at f8. White tries the queen sacrifice anyway.

  6. Take the queen.

    Kxh7. The knight takes your rook with check. With the queen on d4 this was the end. Not now.

  7. This is why d6 was the right square. Win the knight.

    Qxf8. You are a queen and a knight ahead for a rook, and your knight still attacks the rook on d1. One square further back, and White's trick did nothing.

What to remember

  • Put your idea in words: what has to happen for the tactic to work?
  • The first move that fits the idea isn't always the right one. List the others before you play.
  • For each candidate, look at your opponent's checks. A check in between is the usual refutation.
  • The simplest winning move is the best one. A queen that can't be taken is worth less than a queen on a safe square.