Situational pin

A piece that is free to move, with nothing valuable behind it, and still can't afford to.

Lesson 9 of 9 in Pin · about 5 min · 3-question quiz · 8 practice puzzles

Lesson notes

The whole lesson in text, with the answers. Play it on the board above first.

  1. White to move. You could take the d6 pawn. There is something better: one black piece has no defender. Attack it.

    Rb1. The knight is attacked. Nothing valuable stands behind it, so surely it can just move away?

  2. Watch what happens when the knight moves.

    • Na5 The knight jumps away…
    • Rb8+ …and the b-file is open. The rook checks, and the king and rook are on the same rank.
    • Ke7 The king has to step aside…
    • Rxh8 …and the rook in the corner is yours.

    The knight wasn't shielding anything. But while it stood on b3 it kept the b-file closed, and that was holding Black's position together.

  3. This is a situational pin. The knight is stuck on b3 because of what would happen on b8.

    Situational pin: A piece that is legally free to move, with nothing more valuable behind it, but moving it loses to a tactic such as a check, a fork or a mate.

  4. Black tries to get out by offering a trade of knights on c5. Take it, and keep the b-file in mind.

    Nxc5. The knights are gone and the b-file is open again.

  5. Now cash in.

    Rb8+. Check, the king steps aside, and you take the rook on h8 next move. The trade changed nothing.

  6. A harder one. White to move. Your queen and bishop both point at b7, but it is guarded for now. Start the same way: attack a loose piece.

    Rd1. The bishop is attacked. Can it move away?

  7. Say the bishop takes the pawn on f5.

    • Bxf5 The bishop leaves the d-file…
    • Rxd8+ …so the rook takes the knight, with check. That knight was guarding b7.
    • Qxd8 The queen takes back…
    • Qxb7# …and the queen takes on b7. Checkmate.

    Stepping the king aside instead would have lost the queen. Either way the bishop couldn't move: another situational pin.

  8. So Black defends the bishop with the queen. Now it is an ordinary pin: the bishop can't move without losing the queen. Add one more attacker.

    e4. Two attackers, one defender, and the bishop is pinned to the queen. One more attacker than it has defenders, and a pinned piece falls.

  9. One from the other side. It is Black's move, and the pawn on g2 has no defender. Should the knight take it?

    No, the knight won't get out. Right. See why.

  10. Suppose Black takes the pawn.

    • Nxg2 The knight takes on g2, attacking a rook…
    • Reg1 …the rook steps to g1 and attacks the knight. Look at what is behind the knight on that file.
    • Nh4 Say the knight goes back…
    • Nf6+ …now the g7 pawn is pinned to its king and can't take. The knight forks king and queen.

    So the knight on g2 can't move, and the rook simply takes it next. The free pawn cost a piece.

What to remember

  • In a situational pin the piece may move, and nothing more valuable is behind it, but moving it loses to a check, a fork or a mate.
  • Look for loose pieces. Attack one and ask what its move would open up.
  • Whatever kind of pin it is, the recipe is the same: bring one more attacker than it has defenders.
  • Before you grab a pawn, check that your piece can get back out.