What if it stood somewhere else?

Picture one piece gone or on another square. If that wins, your job is to make it happen with a move that can't be ignored.

Lesson 3 of 5 in Tactics that almost work · about 7 min · 2-question quiz

Lesson notes

The whole lesson in text, with the answers. Play it on the board above first.

  1. White to move, a quiet opening position. Imagine your pawn on e5 gone. Why would Black's bishop on d5 then be lost?

    The pawn on e6 would be pinned to the king, so it couldn't take back on d5.. Right. With the e-file open, your rook pins that pawn, and your queen takes the bishop for nothing. So the pawn on e5 has to get out of the way without losing time.

  2. Taking the bishop at once just loses the queen: the pawn takes her. First give a check that lets your e-pawn make a capture.

    Nd6+. Check. If the king moves, it loses the right to castle and your attack plays itself. The bishop takes the knight, and now your e-pawn can capture.

  3. If the pawn takes on d6 now, Black's queen steps to c6 and guards the bishop. There is a stronger move. Look at what your queen would attack from d5, and at what happens if the e6 pawn takes her.

    Qxd5. The queen has won a bishop and attacks the rook on a8 and the bishop on d6. If the pawn takes her, your pawn takes on d6 with a discovered check from the rook and wins the queen. Black resigned.

  4. A new position, White to move. You are a pawn up, and trading queens would win slowly. Before you do that: imagine Black's queen anywhere but on d6. What would you play?

    Queen takes f8 with check, and after the king takes, a rook mates on e8.. Right. Black's queen on d6 is the only piece that guards f8 along the diagonal. If she leaves it, the back rank falls to your queen and two rooks.

  5. So the queen has to be pushed or pulled off d6. Find the bishop move that attacks the rook on d7 and also stands between Black's queen and the bishop on a6.

    Bc6. The bishop attacks the rook, and it cuts the queen off from a6, so your queen attacks that bishop too. Black's best is to lose a rook for a bishop. Suppose the queen takes your bishop.

  6. She has left d6. Break in on the back rank.

    Qxf8+. Check. The king has to take.

  7. Finish it.

    Re8#. Checkmate, with the second rook behind the first. The mate was there from the start. Only the queen on d6 hid it.

What to remember

  • When you are ahead, the easy move is to trade. Look once for something better before you do.
  • Ask what you would play if one piece, yours or theirs, stood somewhere else.
  • Then look for the move that forces it: a check, or an attack on two things at once.
  • A move that blocks a defender's line and attacks a piece in the same turn is hard to answer.